How to Make Homemade Marshmallows (Sweetened with Maple Syrup)

This post may contain affiliate links. Affiliate links come at no extra cost to you. These links allow me to share the products I authentically recommend (and use) and support Live Simply by receiving a small commission.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

Real, homemade food is about more than just nourishing the body. Real food is about bringing people together, slowing down, and creating delicious food from simple ingredients.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

Just a few years ago, I probably would have laughed at the idea of making homemade marshmallows. I would have thought, “I don’t have time to make something like marshmallows! What’s the point when you can just buy a bag of marshmallows from the store?”

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

I take a different view now. I see the act of making homemade marshmallows as a special tradition, a joyful family memory, a way to slow down and celebrate good food and good company.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

Marshmallows certainly aren’t something we make on a regular basis, but when we do (mainly over the holidays), the kids find so much joy in both the process and the final result. They love watching the simple ingredients bubble and then form a sweet syrup that magically whips into the fluffiest, sweetest marshmallow candies.


FREE Real Food Crash Course

I get it, switching from processed food to a real food lifestyle can feel overwhelming and confusing. Friend, it doesn’t have to be this way.

Here’s what to expect: 

  • printable charts (real food defined, a seasonal produce guide, meal planning)
  • how to get started with a real food lifestyle
  • how to create a meal plan and stay within a budget
  • 7 real food recipes
  • emails from me to help you along with a real food lifestyle

 


Meal Prep Rules to Simplify and Succeed at Real Food Prep

While the act of making something like marshmallows may seem small and trivial, it’s part of the bigger legacy we pass down to our kids. A legacy that celebrates slowing down, creating something special with the people we love, sharing that something special, and enjoying every step of the process.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

I hope these marshmallows become a sweet holiday tradition for your family, too. A tradition that celebrates the joy of making and savoring good food with the people you love.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

How to Make Homemade Marshmallows (Sweetened with Maple Syrup)

How to make homemade marshmallows with maple syrup. 

Course Dessert, How To
Cuisine American
Keyword How to Make Marshmallos
Prep Time 12 hours 30 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 12 hours 50 minutes
Servings 20 marshmallows, depending on size
Calories 53 kcal
Author Kristin Marr

Ingredients

Marshmallows:

Dusting the Marshmallows:

Special Equipment:

Instructions

  1. Line a baking pan with parchment paper(optional), and sprinkle the parchment (or pan) with a layer of the arrowroot and powdered sugar mixture (or just arrowroot). 

  2. In a large bowl, sprinkle the gelatin evenly over 1/2 cup of water. Don’t stir, just let it rest. 

  3. In a medium-size saucepan, stir together the maple syrup, 1/2 cup of water, and salt. Add a candy thermometer to the edge of the pan. Turn the heat up to high and bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce to medium heat. Heat the maple syrup mixture until it reaches 238F (around soft candy stage). 

  4. With a hand-mixer on low speed, pour the maple mixture slowly into the gelatin. Add the vanilla extract. Increase the speed to medium/high and beat the mixture for about 10 minutes, or until ready. It's really easy to over-beat the mixture when using a stand-mixer, which is why I recommend using a hand-mixer. If you're using a stand-mixer, don't walk away from the mixture. Pay close attention to the change in texture. You might need to reduce the beating time for a stand-mixer as well. You'll know your mixture is ready when it's thicker, fluffy, and white. 

  5. Once ready, the marshmallow mixture should be thick, fluffy, and white. You can spoon a small amount on a plate to see if it maintains a shape. 

  6. Add the marshmallow mixture to the prepared baking pan. Sprinkle the marshmallows with more of the arrowroot and sugar mixture (or just arrowroot) to evenly coat the top. Spread the mixture evenly over the marshmallows with your hands, if needed. 

  7. Let the marshmallows rest overnight or up to 24 hours (particularly for a very humid climate). It’s best to let the marshmallows rest uncovered so they can dry out. I’ve been successful with just a few hours of resting time when the humidity is low. You can test for readiness by cutting a small piece. The individual piece should be dry. If you cut the marshmallows too early (they still need more drying time), keep the cut marshmallows in the baking pan until fully dry. 

  8. Store the marshmallows in an air-tight container or bag. I’ve found they are best stored in the freezer (a cool, dry place). They won’t freeze to a solid due to the gelatin, so they’re always ready to enjoy. The marshmallows should keep in the freezer for up to 3-4 months. 

Recipe Notes

* If you want super sweet marshmallows, go with the powdered sugar and arrowroot mixture. At this point, I just use arrowroot flour starch and skip the powdered sugar. I find the marshmallows are plenty sweet with just the maple syrup. If you don't want to use arrowroot, or can't find it, try organic cornstarch.

I know, a candy thermometer is a speciality tool, and you'll probably never use this tool again (if you're like me). Well, except to make more marshmallows. This thermometer is very important. Without one, it's difficult to know when the maple syrup mixture has reached the correct temperature.

Homemade marshmallows melt much faster than store-bought marshmallows. We have made s'mores with these marshmallows, but they can be finicky and melt quickly over a very hot flame. It's best to toast them for a short period of time over low heat. They will also slowly melt in a hot drink. These are also delicious to eat as a candy treat.

How to make delicious, homemade, fluffy marshmallows. Sweetened with maple syrup.

Share This Recipe

See my lifestyle in real life

More from Kristin Marr

Live Simply, The Podcast Episode 023: The Encouragement You Need to Grow Your Own Food with Lacey from The Rab Farm

This post may contain affiliate links. Affiliate links come at no extra...
Read More

13 Comments

  • Hmmm. I’m curious about doing it with honey (I love cinnamon, honey, and chocolate, together! ) Do you think this would work with honey, too?

  • Hi,
    I was so excited to read this,

    I can’t find where ot says how many eggs, I know most likely sleep deprivation is the reason I can’t find it.

    Thanks so much

    Kim

  • I am so sorry,

    They looked like they did and I literally read the recipe at least 100 times,

    I have been trying extremely hard to find actual recipes that go with what our holistic healer has my husband eat, doesn’t fit into most categories,

    He can have milk, as long as raw, some grains but have to be soaked,

    I was sure that I missed the part that had the amount, still making with my 7 year old, just wanted to make sure I had what I needed.

    Thank you so much

  • I’m pretty sure I just overbeat the mixture, it came out like cottage cheese and definitely wasn’t pourable into the pan. :-0. I used my stand mixer on max speed, definitely happens faster to get the right consistency.

    • Wish I would have read this comment before I did it! Ours were a lumpy, gelatin-y mixture. I guess I should have been watching my stand mixture more carefully! Will try again and next time pay more attention.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *